From looking over this blog's (brief) history, I guess it must be nearly impossible for me to write a post without making a follow-up to it. So, well, here's another one.
After giving dishers some more thought, it occurred to me that some types would be unsuitable or at least inconvenient for left-handed people to use. Basically, the sweeper in the scoop can be actuated in one of two ways, either by squeezing the entire handle or by pressing a thumb lever. Squeeze-handle dishers are actually ambidextrous, but to my knowledge thumb-lever dishers are only made for right-handed use. For the dishers listed in my previous post, I've made a chart of which ones are left-hand friendly:
Size
Adcraft (metal)
Adcraft (plastic)
Fox Run
Hamilton Beach
Johnson Rose
Norpro
OXO
Vollrath (metal)
Vollrath (plastic)
Zeroll
6
No
No
No
No
Yes
8
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
10
No
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
12
No
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
16
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
20
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
24
No
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
30
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
40
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
50
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
60
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
70
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
100
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
THE TAKEAWAY
If you're left-handed, give squeeze-handle dishers (ice cream scoops) your top consideration. To learn more about disher sizes, see my previous post.
Something that is often not considered when it comes to dishers with left handed cooks is that it isn't really the handle that is the problem. It is the sweeper inside the scoop.
ReplyDeleteWhen used properly, the sweeper should be clear of the "cutting" edge of the scoop. Then the handle sweeps the sweeper through what's been scooped.
When a lefty uses a disher the sweeper is on the cutting edge and it gets pushed out of place, particularly with harder foods, like ice cream, or squash. Then the sweeper is useless to sweep and remove the food.
What we really need is a disher where the sweeper is on the reverse side.
YES!!! Thanks for pointing this out.
DeleteAt last! Someone has pinpointed the problem! I'm amazed a true left scoop has not been invented yet. I do a google search every few years, but nothing...
DeleteYES! THIS!
DeleteSame here. Who will make this product??
DeleteAmazing that no one considers this! There is a trigger ice cream scoop made by Stockel which is German! It is EXPENSIVE but truly left handed!!
DeleteExactly!!!
DeleteThat's a very good point. I thought about the sweeper's position and movement while food is being released from the disher (and figured it didn't matter, so didn't write about it), but not while food is scooped into it. In this right-handed world, I don't think any dishers are made fully left-handed. Perhaps a left-handed cook can squeeze the handle while scooping and relax it while releasing food, but that seems pretty inconvenient as well.
ReplyDeleteYES! I was going to try that (squeeze first, then scoop), but I didn't get the opportunity to test it at my former workplace. The boss suggested I just learn (instantaneously) to scoop with my right hand.
DeleteOk, so where can I get a left-handed ice cream scoop where the little wire inside the scoop swings in the right direction for left-handers??
ReplyDeleteI'm not aware of any scoops made that way. As I mentioned in the previous reply, left-handers will have to adapt by reversing the squeeze/open actions.
ReplyDeleteyou try scooping it squeezed and then released its easier said than done. isnt there any way of reverseing the scraper arm so that it can be used by leftys easier? companys should be more considerate of all their clients not just the majority.
ReplyDeleteNice info here. Keep us these great posts!
ReplyDeleteI also agree! I work with someone who is a Lefty, and the scooper companies need to make a scoop that is exactly like the right handed scoop, except opposite in the position of the thumb and the sweeper! While it is kind of funny to watch them try and scoop with a right handed scoop, it is also less productive and I know very very frustrating for them! These companies just need to get over themselves and Make thing exactly as they do for Righties, just opposite... for Lefties!
ReplyDeleteYes!!!
DeleteI have a small scooper I use for cookies. And I spend more time popping the dough out with my finger. It's messy and not that easy. I like the idea of the scoop but geesh can't they consider us lefty's. I hadn't considered a squeeze handle I'll have to see if I can find a small one for cookies. the scoop keeps the cookies all about the same size. My husband has to have his cookies. They're more of us leftys than the manufacture's want to admit.
ReplyDeleteOne would think that there would be some left-handed scoops out there somewhere, after all, they make left-handed scissors.
ReplyDeleteIt looks like this one would work for lefty's. I have always wanted a cookie scoop, but never could find one that was truly ambidextrous.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.kitchenkrafts.com/product.asp?pn=BE3298&utm_medium=shoppingengine&utm_source=googlebase&sid=GoogleProdAd&tid=CSE&cvsfa=2792&cvsfe=2&cvsfhu=424533323938&gclid=CO6eg9-Tl7ECFeUBQAodfDOKeA
This might work, but it is a spoon and not a scoop and does not come in different sizes. When you work in a kitchen you need different sizes for different chores.
ReplyDeleteMy ice cream scoop has a thumb release in the middle. Instead of sliding the ice cream, dough or batter with the wire band, it just pushes or dumps the material out into the bowl. Complete ambidexterous! Unfortunately, this very useful tool is very, very hard to find and I have not seen it at all in the various sizes other than "large ice cream scoop"!
ReplyDeleteAnonymous 12/24/12 w/the ambidexterous ice cream scoop...where did you get it? I need something for cupcake batter. I am getting better at using my right hand, but as everyone else said, it's not the lever as much as the sweeper.
ReplyDeleteHow hard can it be to make some scoops with the thumb release on the opposite side for left handed cooks I'm sure they would sell just as many scoops. Right now I use a right handed one but the lever is always in the potatoes.I've tried the one with the lever in the middle but it just isn't the same.
ReplyDeleteWell, there are 1/10 as many lefties as there are righties, so they would probably only sell 1/10 as many scoops. Still, on a planet with over 7 billions people, that's still a lot of lefties. You'd think it would be worth it. And I daresay many of us would pay a premium to get a product that works for us.
DeleteI have looked all over the internet for a scoop with a sweep on the left side. Found one on an Aussie site but they were out and didn't expect any more. It is SO frustrating! We lefties get by with a lot of things in this right-handed world but this is one thing I'd really like to get my hands on. I have ruined several of the ones with the sweep on the right side - even better quality ones. Arggh!
ReplyDeleteBoth my son and his girlfriend are left handed. The only way they can use a cookie dough scoop is to fill it right handed then switch to left to place on the cookie sheet. So frustrating for them and frustrating for me that I can't seem to find a left handed one to put in their Christmas stockings!!
ReplyDeleteThe real problem is the wear on the sweeper. I've been using right handed dishers for 30 yrs and the worst thing about no lefty scoops is breaking them all the time. So we lefties help sell more scoops by manufacturers not catering to our needs...Don't hold your breath in anticipation of a lefty scoop any time soon.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.tigerchef.com/thunder-group-slds012-3-1-3-oz-ice.html?mkwid=s_dm&pcrid=103997748082&pkw=&pmt=&plc=&gclid=CjwKCAiAqOriBRAfEiwAEb9oXTZ8FGVOj633okOPnsBf2Xl3pkNOCCTcUV2_6cFQNEhc_Bq4IamBVhoCfuYQAvD_BwE this looks like it's left handed?
ReplyDeleteIt's easy to think that a utensil is ambidextrous, but as the husband of a lefty and father of a lefty, I've got my ears filled with how such things are NOT!
ReplyDeleteYes, the first problem is that the sweep is on the wrong side for leftys that, combined with the squeeze motion makes these things NOT ambidextrous. If you think about the mechanics; when a righty uses one of these squeeze handle scoops, their fingers are doing the squeezing, and the sweep is on the opposite side. If a lefty uses the same device, the base of their thumb is doing all the work; the forces on the handles aren't equivalent to using it righthanded. I can't tell you how many times ours have jammed. And then if you try to remember to squeeze the handles first, so the sweep is on the opposite side, you have to do something which is non-intuitive.
Frankly in these days of computer aided design and drafting, it shouldn't be hard to take the design drawings, flip them electronically , and actually engineer them properly to be truly lefthanded.
Come on, utensil mfr's, do it CORRECTLY!!